Player of the Year
- 2011: Erick Gaylord, Watertown
- 2012: Ross Kivett, Glens Falls
- 2013: John Nogowski, Amsterdam
- 2014: Josh Gardiner, Amsterdam
- 2015: Christian Santisteban, Elmira
- 2016: Joe Genord, Amsterdam
- 2017: Christ Conley, Jamestown
- 2018: Ryan Toohers, Mohawk Valley
- 2019: Max Costes, Amsterdam
- 2020: Season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic
- 2021: Griffin O’Ferrall, Auburn
- 2022: Gage Miller, Amsterdam
- 2023: Andrew Amato, Saugerties
- 2024: Cade Ladehoff, Amsterdam
Pitcher of the Year
- 2011: Dominick Ruscitti, Newark
- 2012: Chandler Shepherd, Amsterdam
- 2013: Eann Cox, Cooperstown
- 2014: Jayson Yano, Newark
- 2015: Zach Logue, Amsterdam; Kyano Cummings, Elmira
- 2016: Joe DeSarro, Mohawk Valley; Brennen Smith, Victor
- 2017: Matt Pierce, Albany
- 2018: Mason Hazelwood, Elmira
- 2019: Lane Miller, Saugerties
- 2020: Season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic
- 2021: Nick Smith, Amsterdam
- 2022: Nolan Sparks, Batavia
- 2023: Aidan Colagrande, Mohawk Valley
- 2024: Gage Rowe, Auburn
Coach of the Year
- 2011: Eric Coleman, Cooperstown
- 2012: Keith Griffin, Amsterdam
- 2013: Nick Davey, Albany
- 2014: Mike Armstrong, Newark
- 2015: Dan Shwam, Victor
- 2016: Blake Nation, Mohawk Valley
- 2017: Anthony Barone, Jamestown
- 2018: Anthony Barone, Jamestown
- 2019: Mickey Fauvelle, Adirondack
- 2020: Season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic
- 2021: Rich Dubee, Saugerties
- 2022: Keith Griffin, Amsterdam
- 2023: (co-winners) Joey Martinez, Batavia & Keith Griffin, Amsterdam
- 2024: Keith Griffin, Amsterdam
Top Professional Prospect
- 2011: Erick Gaylord, Watertown (Perfect Game USA), Josh Anderson, Glens Falls (Baseball America)
- 2012: Rocky McCord, Amsterdam (Perfect Game USA), Chandler Shepherd, Amsterdam (Baseball America)
- 2013: Mike Urbanski, Amsterdam (Perfect Game USA), Trey Wingenter, Amsterdam (Baseball America)
- 2014: Jon Escobar, Watertown (Perfect Game USA)
- 2015: Kyle Smith, Amsterdam (Perfect Game USA)
- 2016: Jeff Belge, Amsterdam (Perfect Game USA)
- 2017: T.J. Collett, Amsterdam (Perfect Game USA & Baseball America)